All comments are owned by those who posted them, and do not reflect the opinions of EatInFrederick.com or its employees. If you have a concern about a specific comment, please contact us.
From: Vallerie
Since the first time I tried it, I loved it. Wish I still lived there so I could eat it everyday. That's what I miss most about Middletown. The Manicotti was my favorite, but it was all wonderful. I loved the people that worked there! They were awesome too!
From: Anonymous
I agree ... the bacon cheese fries are the best! I also agree that the crust is like card board on the pizza. But hey it's good in a pinch!
From: Anonymous
They used to deliver twice a week to Middletown Elementary so now eating there is more sentimental than anything else. But I will admit their calzone is rather delicious
From: Anonymous
their food is okay. if you want to get food thats good in Middletown go to Wing N Pizza Shack at BP.
From: Annonymous
Try the Ed's Sampler platter, it's very good.
Their pizza is okay, I'm not a fan of the sauce, (it's too sweet).
From: Anonymous
The food at James Gang is mediocre at best. Actually dining in the restaurant is terrible... the service was excruciatingly slow and there were flies everywhere! I'd hate to see what the kitchen looks like. I would definitely NOT recommend this restaurant to anyone.
From: Anonymous
Great place to catch very good pizza's & overstuffed subs. People are very nice and the bacon, cheese fries are the best around.
Wonderful menu variations and the owners always support our Middletown Community.
Thanks
From: Richard Nixon
Go for the sicilian pizza if you are going to get pizza... it is quite tasty and a good value for a filling pizza. Of course, everything pales in comparison to John's Pizzeria in New York City, but we do live here so we have to make the best of it.
From: Jason
I've lived in the Myersville/Middletown area for 26 years and James Gang has always been one of my favorite resturants. Good Subs, good pizza, good service and the food isn't inexpensive.
From: Alex Athey
A good local restaurant. The food is quite good, finding a fine balance between cost and quality. Nice atmosphere and generally solid service makes for worthy restaurant.
From: Richard
Wings are top notch!! try the hot sauce gently poured over each wing.WOW!!
pizza is ok but not New York style which is my favorite. I am a very picky eater so i require a italian style mozzarella cheese.
From: Anonymous
THE PIZZA ARE NOT THAT BAD BUT THE SANDWICH ARE SO GOOD AND MOZZ. CHEESE STICK ARE WAY GOOD!
From: Christine
Their pizza isn't anything to brag about. Their subs are ok as long as they get your order right.
From: Anonymous
Local place with ok pizza, but sauce is way to spicy for us members of the acid reflux club. Try the weggies for something a little tamer.
From: Anonymous
Good place to go in a pinch. Subs are ok. Pizza is average at best. Anyone saying this is good pizza has not tasted what pizza is supposed to be like.
From: Anonymous
Its ok but trust me if you live in Middletown and want to go somewhere nice you much go to Collamors Deli!! Its delicious and the best place to eat here!
From: Anonymous
Pizza crust tastes like card board!!
Subs are okay.
From: MB
Pizza is among the best, and atmosphere is very nice small town.
From: Anonymous
Food is good
From: Paul
Everything I've ever eaten here has been delicious. Subs, fries, pizza, and all the other types of Italian that end in -ini or -one. A real treat to be able to enjoy.
From: william
The pizza and subs are soooo good. Very local atmosphere. Good palce to go eat with some friends.
From: Anonymous
Very VERY good pizza.
From: mrmourning
Great subs, and ok pizza. A great place to get a bite locally.
From: Anonymous
Below average pizza
From: Jimmy Peyton
A great place to sit down for a pizza, sub, or italian dish. Prices are pretty average, along with the service. Great pizzeria atmosphere. For the price the food is very good.
From: Vallerie
Since the first time I tried it, I loved it. Wish I still lived there so I could eat it everyday. That's what I miss most about Middletown. The Manicotti was my favorite, but it was all wonderful. I loved the people that worked there! They were awesome too!
From: Anonymous
I agree ... the bacon cheese fries are the best! I also agree that the crust is like card board on the pizza. But hey it's good in a pinch!
From: Anonymous
They used to deliver twice a week to Middletown Elementary so now eating there is more sentimental than anything else. But I will admit their calzone is rather delicious
From: Anonymous
their food is okay. if you want to get food thats good in Middletown go to Wing N Pizza Shack at BP.
From: Annonymous
Try the Ed's Sampler platter, it's very good.
Their pizza is okay, I'm not a fan of the sauce, (it's too sweet).
From: Anonymous
The food at James Gang is mediocre at best. Actually dining in the restaurant is terrible... the service was excruciatingly slow and there were flies everywhere! I'd hate to see what the kitchen looks like. I would definitely NOT recommend this restaurant to anyone.
From: Anonymous
Great place to catch very good pizza's & overstuffed subs. People are very nice and the bacon, cheese fries are the best around.
Wonderful menu variations and the owners always support our Middletown Community.
Thanks
From: Richard Nixon
Go for the sicilian pizza if you are going to get pizza... it is quite tasty and a good value for a filling pizza. Of course, everything pales in comparison to John's Pizzeria in New York City, but we do live here so we have to make the best of it.
From: Jason
I've lived in the Myersville/Middletown area for 26 years and James Gang has always been one of my favorite resturants. Good Subs, good pizza, good service and the food isn't inexpensive.
From: Alex Athey
A good local restaurant. The food is quite good, finding a fine balance between cost and quality. Nice atmosphere and generally solid service makes for worthy restaurant.
From: Richard
Wings are top notch!! try the hot sauce gently poured over each wing.WOW!!
pizza is ok but not New York style which is my favorite. I am a very picky eater so i require a italian style mozzarella cheese.
From: Anonymous
THE PIZZA ARE NOT THAT BAD BUT THE SANDWICH ARE SO GOOD AND MOZZ. CHEESE STICK ARE WAY GOOD!
From: Christine
Their pizza isn't anything to brag about. Their subs are ok as long as they get your order right.
From: Anonymous
Local place with ok pizza, but sauce is way to spicy for us members of the acid reflux club. Try the weggies for something a little tamer.
From: Anonymous
Good place to go in a pinch. Subs are ok. Pizza is average at best. Anyone saying this is good pizza has not tasted what pizza is supposed to be like.
From: Anonymous
Its ok but trust me if you live in Middletown and want to go somewhere nice you much go to Collamors Deli!! Its delicious and the best place to eat here!
From: Anonymous
Pizza crust tastes like card board!!
Subs are okay.
From: MB
Pizza is among the best, and atmosphere is very nice small town.
From: Anonymous
Food is good
From: Paul
Everything I've ever eaten here has been delicious. Subs, fries, pizza, and all the other types of Italian that end in -ini or -one. A real treat to be able to enjoy.
From: william
The pizza and subs are soooo good. Very local atmosphere. Good palce to go eat with some friends.
From: Anonymous
Very VERY good pizza.
From: mrmourning
Great subs, and ok pizza. A great place to get a bite locally.
From: Anonymous
Below average pizza
From: Jimmy Peyton
A great place to sit down for a pizza, sub, or italian dish. Prices are pretty average, along with the service. Great pizzeria atmosphere. For the price the food is very good.